The majority of peri/menopausal women who come to see me in clinic are now taking HRT or considering it, which is a big shift from when I started practicing in 2018. One of the most common questions I get asked in clinic, often by women who have just started HRT, or are considering it is
"If I'm on HRT, does what I eat still matter?"
Or the flip side I’m also asked:
"I don't want to take HRT and can nutrition fix my symptoms instead?"
Both are completely valid questions, and both deserve an honest answer. So here is my view not as someone with an agenda either way, but as a nutritionist who works with women navigating this transition every single day. And full disclosure, I take HRT myself; you may know that I had early menopause at 44 but initially resisted it because of the reputational issues which are detailed below. Read on…
First, let's talk about HRT
Hormone Replacement Therapy has had a complicated history and reputation. For years, many women were scared away from it following the WHI study in the early 2000s that linked it to increased health risks. The good news is that the science has moved on considerably, and for most healthy women, modern body identical HRT is now considered safe, effective and for many genuinely life-changing.
HRT works by replacing the oestrogen (and often progesterone) that your ovaries are producing less of. It can dramatically reduce hot flushes, night sweats, mood swings, vaginal dryness, joint pain, and sleep disruption. It also has protective effects on bone density and cardiovascular health when started at the right time.
NB. If you are considering HRT or have questions about whether it is right for you, please speak with a GP, gynaecologist or menopause specialist. It’s not within my remit as a nutritional therapist to advise on medication. A great resource is the My Menopause Centre website https://www.mymenopausecentre.com/
So Where Does Nutrition Come In?
In all honesty, HRT and good nutrition are not competing choices. They work on entirely different systems, and for most women, combining both produces far better outcomes than either alone.
HRT replaces hormones but it doesn’t:
Repair your gut microbiome which directly influences how you process and clear those hormones
Reduce chronic inflammation which amplifies virtually every perimenopausal symptom
Rebuild muscle mass that declines with age and dramatically affects metabolism and long-term health
Stabilise blood sugar which, when dysregulated, worsens hot flushes, mood, energy, and sleep, even on HRT
Support your liver which is responsible for metabolising the hormones HRT delivers
Replenish the micronutrients that perimenopause depletes
In other words, HRT addresses the hormonal piece of the puzzle and nutrition and lifestyle changes addresses everything around it.
What I See in Clinic
I work with women across a wide spectrum some on HRT, some not, some in the early stages of perimenopause, some well into post-menopause. And what I observe consistently is that women on HRT who also eat well tend to do significantly better than those who rely on HRT alone.
Their energy is often more stable and their mood is more resilient, and they maintain muscle and bone density more effectively. They sleep better, and often they need lower doses of HRT to feel well because their body is better equipped to work with it.
On the other side, I also see women who have chosen not to take HRT for personal, medical, or cultural reasons and who have made remarkable improvements through nutritional intervention alone. It’s not always a complete solution, and I will always be honest when I think someone needs medical support; but nutrition can move the dial considerably, even without HRT.
The Key Nutritional Pillars Alongside HRT
Whether you are on HRT or not, these are the areas I focus on most in clinic:
1. Blood Sugar Balance
Fluctuating blood sugar is one of the biggest drivers of perimenopausal symptoms and it is almost entirely within our control through diet. Protein at every meal, avoiding refined carbohydrates, not skipping meals, and eating within a reasonable window all make a significant difference.
2. Gut Health
Your gut microbiome contains a community of bacteria called the oestrobolome, which helps regulate oestrogen levels in the body. A disrupted gut can lead to oestrogen being reabsorbed rather than cleared contributing to hormonal imbalance. Fermented foods, fibre diversity, and reducing ultra-processed foods all support this.
3. Liver Support
Your liver processes hormones both the ones your body makes and those delivered by HRT. A sluggish liver means hormones are not cleared efficiently. Cruciferous vegetables (broccoli, cauliflower, Brussels sprouts), adequate hydration, and reducing alcohol all support liver function.
4. Protein and Muscle Mass
From our mid-thirties onwards, we begin to lose muscle mass; a process that accelerates during perimenopause. Muscle is metabolically active tissue; losing it slows your metabolism, weakens your bones, and affects your blood sugar regulation. Most women I see are significantly under-eating protein. Aim for a palm-sized portion at every single meal.
5. Anti-Inflammatory Eating
Oestrogen has natural anti-inflammatory properties. As it declines, many women notice they feel more achy, more reactive, and more inflamed. An anti-inflammatory diet rich in oily fish, colourful vegetables, olive oil, nuts, and seeds helps compensate for this.
6. Targeted Nutrients
My top three are magnesium for sleep and anxiety, Vitamin D for mood, immunity, and bone health and Omega-3s for brain health and inflammation. B vitamins can be useful for energy and nervous system support. These by no means replace HRT but they create the nutritional environment in which your body can function at its best.
My Honest Answer to the Question: Do you need both HRT and good nutrition?
If you are on HRT: yes, nutrition still matters enormously. Think of HRT as addressing the hormonal foundation, and nutrition as building everything on top of it because one without the other can leave significant gaps.
If you’re not on HRT: nutrition becomes even more important, because your body has fewer hormonal resources to draw on. It can’t do everything, but it can do a great deal.
And if you are undecided about HRT: please don’t let the nutrition vs. medication framing push you one way or the other. These are not opposing camps, a good nutritionist and a good menopause doctor should work towards exactly the same goal in helping you feel well in your body during one of its biggest transitions.
Personalisation is key…
One thing I feel strongly about is that perimenopausal nutrition is not one-size-fits-all. The woman who is struggling primarily with sleep needs a different focus than the woman whose main issue is joint pain or anxiety or weight gain. We’re all biochemically individual and what works brilliantly for one person may be irrelevant for another.
If you would like to explore what a personalised nutrition approach could do for you whether you are on HRT or not, please get in touch I’d love to hear from you x
